path: root/README

$Header$

pgpool version 3.4.1 README

1. What is pgpool

   pgpool is a connection server for PostgreSQL. pgpool runs between
   PostgreSQL's clients(front ends) and servers(back ends). A
   PostgreSQL client can connect to pgpool as if it were a standard
   PostgreSQL server.

   pgpool caches the connection to PostgreSQL server to reduce the
   overhead to establish the connection to it.

   Also, pgpool could use two PostgreSQL servers for fail over. If the
   first server goes down, pgpool will automatically switch to the
   secondary server.

   Moreover, pgpool supports scheduled switch over. See
   "10. Switchover" for more details.

1.1 About replication facility of pgpool

   pgpool could be used as a replication server. This allows real-time
   backuping of the database to avoid disk failures. pgpool sends
   exactly the same updating queries to each PostgreSQL servers to
   accomplish replication. So pgpool can be regarded as a "synchronous
   replication server".  Currently pgpool supports up to 2 PostgreSQL
   servers.

   Please note that some sort of quries such as random functions, OID,
   XID, timestamp may not be replicated in exactly same value among
   two servers. This is because qury results for these are local to
   each PostgreSQL server.

   If you want to use SERIAL data type, "insert_lock" might help
   you. See "insert_lock" in "6. Setting up pgpool.conf" for more
   details.

   When one of PostgreSQL server goes down, pgpool tries to continue
   serverce with live server. This is called "degeneration mode".
   When you want to come back to the replication mode, please make
   sure that the DB contens matches among two servers. The best way is
   shutdown the live server and do a physical copy using rsync from
   the live server to the dead server. Once the DB contents match you
   start the two postmaster then restart pgpool.

   While pgpool is in the replication mode, SELECT queries are sent to
   the master node only if "replicate_select" is false. If the load
   balancing is enabled, SELECT's are sent to randomly chosen node. If
   you need to replicate a SELECT query which has a side effect of
   updaing some data, append the following comment at the beginning of
   the query.

      /*REPLICATION*/ SELCT ...

   Note that queries that begin with either "SELECT nextval" or
   "SELECT setval" are automatically replicated. If "replicate_select"
   is true, SELECTs are replicated.

1.2 Avoiding deadlocks

   pgpool could send a query to the "master" server then send to
   "secondary" server before master completes the query. This could
   improve performace, there's a risk of deadlock however. To balance
   the performace and risk, pgpool could operate in two modes.

   1) "restrict" mode

   In this mode, pgpool wait for the completion of the master query
   before sending a query to the secondary server. This is the safest
   and default operating mode for pgpool.

   2) using /*STRICT*/ keyword

   To achieve best performance, you could turn off the strict mode by
   setting off to "pgpool_restrict" directive. To avoid deadlock, you
   could insert a special keyword /*STRICT*/ in the beginning of each
   deadlock-possible quries. Here is an example:

   /*STRICT*/ LOCK TABLE t1;

1.3 what happens if a deadlock ocuurs?

   Since deadlocks mentioned above cannot be detected by PostgreSQL
   itself, pgpool will abort the session if master or secondary does
   not respond within certain period. The period can be changed by
   setting replication_timeout directive.

1.4 about load balancing mode

   If replication is enabled, you can enjoy the load balancing
   capability of pgpool by enabling load_balance_mode in
   pgpool.conf. If conditions below are all meet, SELECT queries are
   distributed among the master and the slave server in random manner,
   which will boost performance:

   1) protocol version is V3. this means the backend must be
      PostgreSQL 7.4 or later.

   2) the query begins with "SELECT" or "select" (case is ignored). no
      space is allowed before "SELECT".

   3) SELECT query is not in a transatcion block.

   Please note that a SELECT may modify databases by calling a
   updatable function. In this case you should NOT use the load
   balancing. Othewise pgpool will fail due to the contents difference
   between the master and the secondary database. You can avoid the
   load balancing by putting spaces or comments in the begining of the
   query.

   BTW, since the regression test includes such a SELECT (for example
   "SELECT 'one' AS one, nextval('insert_seq');" in the constraints
   test), the regression test will fail if the load balancing mode is
   enabled.

2. Advantages of pgpool

   There are some connection pool servers other than pgpool. This
   section explains why you should use pgpool:

   1) you do not need to modify your applications

   There are some connection pool servers which require special
   API(Application Program Interface) to play with them. Since pgpool
   looks like PostgreSQL server from the client's point of view,
   existing PostgreSQL applications can be used without any
   modifications.

   2) any programming languages can be used

   Since pgpool is not an API, applications written in any languages
   including PHP, Perl and Java can be used.

   3) employing prefork architecture

   pgpool employing prefork architecture, meaning no need to start up
   process for each connection from its clients, gives better
   performance.

   4) resource usage control

   pgpool can limit number of connections to PostgreSQL server. Users
   could avoid too much load of PostgreSQL by using pgpool especially
   under Web application environment.

   5) fail over

   pgpool has a functionality so called "fail over". If the first
   server goes down, pgpool will automatically switch to the secondary
   server.

   6) replication

   pgpool can be used as a replication server.

   7) load balancing

   SELECT statement can be distributed among servers to gain more performance.

3. Disadvantage of pgpool

   1) overhead

   Any access to PostgreSQL must go through pgpool, which means some
       overhead is added to each database access. In my testing using
       pgbench shows 7 to 15% performance penalty. This number may
       vary for each testing environment though.

   2) not all libpq protocols are supported

   currently following protocols are not supported:

   o any authentication methods except "trust", "clear text password",
     "pam" (replication or master/slave mode)

   o any authentication methods except "trust", "clear text password",
     "crypt", "md5", "pam" (non replication mode)

   3) no access control to pgpool using pg_hba.conf

   Any client can connect to pgpool. If this is your concern, you
   could limit access by using another software such as iptables.

4. supported environments

   pgpool supports libpq protocol version 2(employed by PostgreSQL 6.4
   to 7.3). If you are going to use with PostgreSQL 7.2 or earlier,
   you need to modify following line in pgpool.conf.

   7.1 or earlier:
   reset_query_list = 'ABORT'

   7.2.x:
   reset_query_list = 'ABORT, RESET ALL'

   7.3 or later:
   reset_query_list = 'ABORT, RESET ALL, SET SESSION AUTHORIZATION DEFAULT'
   (currently the default value in pgpool.conf. so you don't need to
   change it)

   Here are small lists from users where pgpool is running:

   Vine Linux 4.0 (kernel 2.6.16-0vl166)/PostgreSQL 8.2.1
   Vine Linux 3.2 (kernel 2.4.31-0vl1.10)/PostgreSQL 8.1.1
   Vine Linux 2.6r4 (kernel 2.4.22-0vl2.12)/PostgreSQL 8.1.0
   Vine Linux 2.6r4 (kernel 2.4.22-0vl2.12)/PostgreSQL 8.0.3
   Vine Linux 2.6r4 (kernel 2.4.22-0vl2.12)/PostgreSQL 8.0
   Vine Linux 2.6r4 (kernel 2.4.22-0vl2.12)/PostgreSQL 7.4.5
   Vine Linux 2.6r4 (kernel 2.4.22-0vl2.12)/PostgreSQL 7.4.3
   Vine Linux 2.6r4 (kernel 2.4.22-0vl2.12)/PostgreSQL 7.4.2
   Vine Linux 2.6r4 (kernel 2.4.22-0vl2.12)/PostgreSQL 7.3.7
   Vine Linux 2.6r4 (kernel 2.4.22-0vl2.12)/PostgreSQL 7.3.6
   Vine Linux 2.6r3 (kernel 2.4.22-0vl2.8)/PostgreSQL 7.4.2
   Vine Linux 2.6r3 (kernel 2.4.22-0vl2.8)/PostgreSQL 7.3.6
   Vine Linux 2.6CR (kernel 2.4.20-0vl29.1)/PostgreSQL 7.3.4
   RedHat Linux 9.0 (kernel 2.4.20)/PostgreSQL 7.3.6
   RedHat Linux 8.0 (kernel 2.4.18-14)/PostgreSQL 7.3.2
   RedHat Linux 6.2 (kernel 2.2.24)/PostgreSQL 7.2.1
   FreeBSD 5.2.1-RELEASE(AMD64)/PostgreSQL 7.4.3
   FreeBSD 5.2.1-RELEASE/PostgreSQL 7.3?
   FreeBSD 4.7-RELEASE/PostgreSQL 7.2.4 
   FreeBSD 4.2-RELEASE/PostgreSQL 7.3.2
   Sparc/Solaris8/PostgreSQL 7.3
   Sparc/Solaris8/PostgreSQL 7.4.3

5. How to install pgpool

      ./configure
      make
      make install

      of course "make" should be read as "gmake" if you are using
      FreeBSD or Solaris.

      Default installation directories are:

      /usr/local/bin/pgpool			pgpool executable
      /usr/local/etc/pgpool.conf.sample		example configuration file
      /usr/local/etc/pool_hba.conf.sample	example HBA configuration file

      You could change the installation directory by giving --prefix
      option to configure:
      
      configure --prefix=path... 

6. Setting up pgpool.conf

   pgpool.conf is the configuration file for pgpool.

   Copy pgpool.conf.sample as pgpool.conf and change it if necessary.

   Here is a explanation of pgpool.conf's grammar.

   1) configuration variables can be set by:

      item = value

      pair.

   2) if the value is a numeric, just write numerics. If the value is
      a string, you need to quote using single quote pair. example:
      
      'foo'

   3) empty lines are ignored

   4) lines starting with # are ignored.


   Here is a list of existing items:

   listen_addresses

   Specifies the addresses to listen on for TCP/IP connections.  Set
   to '*' for all configured IP interfaces, '' for no TCP/IP
   connections, or else to a specific IP address or host name.  The
   default is 'localhost'.  Note that connections via UNIX domain
   sockets are always allowed.

   (For compatibility with earlier versions of pgpool,
   allow_inet_domain_socket = 1 means listen_addresses = '*' and
   allow_inet_domain_socket = 0 means listen_addresses = ''.)

   port

   the port number where pgpool is running on. Default value is 9999.

   backend_host_name

   the real PostgreSQL server name pgpool could connect. Default
   value is '' (empty string), which means pgpool will connect via
   UNIX domain sockets. Any string other than '' is considered as a
   host name where the PostgreSQL server is running. In this case the
   pg_hba.conf file must be properly set so that pgpool could connect
   to.

   backend_port

   the port number where real PostgreSQL server is running on. Default
   value is 5432.

   secondary_backend_host_name

   if you are going to use fail over or replication functionality of
   pgpool, you need to set the hostname or ''. Default value is ''.

   secondary_backend_port

   if you are going to use fail over or replication functionality of
   pgpool, you need to set the port number where PostgreSQL is running
   on. Default value is 0, which means the fail over functionality is
   disabled.

   num_init_children

   number of pgpool process initially forked. Default value is 32.

   max_pool

   number of connection pools each pgpool server process are keeping.
   pgpool will make a new connection if there's no user name and
   database name pair yet. Thus it is recommended that max_pool
   exceeds the number of such that possible pairs. If it exceeds, the
   oldest connection is discarded and the new connection uses the
   slot. The default value is 4.

   note that the total number of connections to the PostgreSQL server
   can be calculated by following:

   num_init_children*max_pool

   child_life_time

   Life of a idle child process in seconds. This will prevent unwanted
   memory leaks or other problems. Default is 300. Set it to 0
   disables this feature.

   connection_life_time

   life time for each idle connection in seconds. 0 means the life
   time is forever. The default value is 0.

   child_max_connections

   if child_max_connections connections were received, child exits. 0
   means no exit. The default value is 0.

   logdir

   the directory name to store pgpool's log files. Currently only a
   file named pgpool.pid(has pgpool's process id) is stored. The
   default value for logdir is '/tmp'.

   replication_mode

   set this true if you are going to use replication
   functionality. Default is false.

   replication_strict

   If true, pgpool will wait for the completion of the master query
   before sending a query to the secondary server. This is the safest
   and default operating mode for pgpool. Default is true.

   replication_timeout

   In non strict replication mode, there will be a chance of
   deadlock. pgpool will abort the session if master or secondary does
   not respond within this milli seconds. if set to 0, timeout is
   disabled.

   load_balance_mode

   Perform load balancing for SELECT. Default is false.

   weight_master
   weight_secondary

   load balance weight for master and secondary. actual weight is
   calculated by weight_master:weight_secondary. For example both

   weight_master = 10 and weight_secondary = 5
   weight_master = 4 and weight_secondary = 2

   are regarded as master has double the weight comparing with
   secondary.  master and secondary have same weight in the default.

   replication_stop_on_mismatch

   Stop replication mode on data mismatch between master and
   secondary. Default is false.

   replicate_select

   Replicate SELECTs. Default is false.

   reset_query_list

   semicolon separated SQL commands to be issued at the end of
   session. Default is as following:

   reset_query_list = 'ABORT; RESET ALL; SET SESSION AUTHORIZATION DEFAULT'

   You may add you own SQL commands to the list. Please note that
   above all queries may not be accepted by all PostgreSQL
   versions(see "4. supported environmets" for more details).

   Note that "ABORT" will not be issued if the backend is 7.4 or later
   and the session is not in a transaction block.

   print_timestamp

   If true timestamp is added to each log line. Default value is true.

   master_slave_mode

   Run in master/slave mode. See 14 for more details. Default value is
   false. This mode is not compatible with replication_mode.

   connection_cache

   If true, cache connections to PostgreSQL. Default value is true.

   health_check_timeout

   pgpool does "health check" periodically to detect PostgreSQL
   servers down, network communication problems or as such. If
   something is going wrong, pgpool will automatically run into fail
   over or degeneration mode.

   This parameter specifies the timeout value in seconds to avoid hung
   up in the health checking. The default is 20. 0 means no timeout.

   The health checking actually connects to PostgreSQL as if it's an
   ordinaly PostgreSQL client. Thus you may need to increase the
   max_connections parameter of PostgreSQL.

   health_check_period

   Specifies the interval for next health checking. 0 means no health
   checking. The default is 0(i.e. no health checking).

   health_check_user

   PostgreSQL user name for the health checking.

   insert_lock

   If you replicate a table having SERIAL data type column, sometimes
   the serial value does not match between servers. You can avoid the
   problem by using a table lock (with a performance penalty due to
   less currency in transactions). For this you need to rewrite you
   query:

   INSERT INTO ....

   to:

   BEGIN;
   LOCK TABLE ...
   INSERT INTO ...
   COMMIT;

   This is painfull. If you turn on insert_lock, pgpool will
   automatically do the rewriting for you.

   Beaware that pgpool is not smart enough that to do the rewriting
   only for tables having SERIAL column. To avoid the problem try one
   of these:

   1) set insert_lock to true and add a /*NO INSERT LOCK*/ comment at
      the beginning of the query. This will prevent the rewriting.

   2) set insert_lock to false and add a /*INSERT LOCK*/ comment at
      the beginning of the query. This will do the rewriting for the
      query only.

   The default value for insert_lock is false.

   Note that turning on insert_lock will make some of the regression
   test fail. As of PostgreSQL 8.0, transactions, privileges, rules,
   alter_table fail. The reason of the failure is table locking for
   views in rule test, and for others erroneous queries abort the
   transaction *before* pgpool issues the table lock statement.

   ignore_leading_white_space

   If true, ignore leading white spaces of each query while pgpool
   judges if the query is a SELECT so that it can be load
   balnced. This is usefull for certain APIs such as DBI/DBD which is
   know as adding an extra leading white space.

   log_statement

   If true, print all statements to the log.  Like the log_statement option
   to PostgreSQL, this allows for observing queries without engaging in full
   debugging.

   log_hostname

   If true, ps command status will show the client's hostname instead
   of an IP address. Also, if log_connections is enabled, hostname will
   be logged.

   log_connections

   If true, all incoming connections will be printed to the log.

   enable_pool_hba

   If true, use pool_hba.conf for client authentication. See
   "7. Setting up pool_hba.conf for client authentication".

7. Setting up pool_hba.conf for client authentication (HBA)

  Just like pg_hba.conf with PostgreSQL, pgpool supports a similar
  client authentication function using a configuration file called 
  "pool_hba.conf".

  When you install pgpool, pool_hba.conf.sample will be installed in
  "/usr/local/etc", which is the default directory for configuration
  files.

  Copy pool_hba.conf.sample as pool_hba.conf and edit it if necessary.
  By default, pool_hba authentication is enabled. See "6. Setting up
  pgpool.conf" for more detail.

  The format of pool_hba.conf file follows very closely to pg_hba.conf.

    local      DATABASE  USER  METHOD  [OPTION]
    host       DATABASE  USER  CIDR-ADDRESS  METHOD  [OPTION]

  See "pool_hba.conf.sample" for details of each field.

  Here are the limitations of pool_hba.

  * "hostssl" connection type is not supported

    "hostssl" is invalid since pgpool currently does not support SSL
    connections.

  * "samegroup" for DATABASE field is not supported

    Since pgpool does not know anything about users in the backend server,
    database name is simply checked against the entries in the DATABASE
    field of pool_hba.conf.

  * group names following "+" for USER field is not supported

    This is the same reason as in the "samegroup" described above. A
    user name is simply checked against the entries in the USER field
    of pool_hba.conf.

  * IPv6 for IP address/mask is not supported

    pgpool currently does not support IPv6.

  * Only "trust", "reject" and "pam" for METHOD field are supported

    Again, this is the same reason as in the "samegroup" described above.
    pgpool does not hold user/password information.
  
  Note that everything described in this section is about a client authen-
  tication between a client and pgpool; a client still have to go through
  an authentication process with PostgreSQL. As far as pool_hba is concerned,
  it does not matter if a user name and/or database name given by a client
  (i.e. psql -U testuser testdb) really exist in the backend. pool_hba only
  cares if a match in the pool_hba.conf is found or not.

  PAM authenticaion is supported using user information on the host where
  pgpool is executed. To enable PAM support in pgpool, specify "--with-pam"
  option to configure:

    configure --with-pam

  To enable PAM authentication, you need to create a
  service-configuration file for pgpool in the system's PAM
  configuration directory (which is usually at "/etc/pam.d"). A sample
  service-configuration file is installed as "share/pgpool.pam" under
  the install directory.

8. Starting pgpool

   The simplist way to start pgpool is:

   $ pgpool

   pgpool will load /usr/local/etc/pgpool.conf.

   available options for pgpool are:

   -f path

   the path to the configuration file.

   -a path

   the path to the pool_hba configuration file.

   -n

   do not start as daemon. Error messages go to stdout or stderr. Thus
   you could play with utilities such as logger and rotatelogs. You
   need to run in background explicitly if you use this option.

   -d

   lots of debugging messages come out

   -h

   print the help message and quit

9. Stopping pgpool

   You can stop pgpool by using "stop" option:

   $ pgpool [-f config_file] -m {s[mart]|f[ast]|i[mmediate]} stop

   If there's any live connection from frontend, it will wait until
   the connection terminated.

   To force it to be stopped, try:

   $ pgpool -m f[ast] stop

   or

   $ pgpool -m i[mmediate] stop

10. switchover

   For maintenance purpose, scheduled switching or degeneration is
   supported.

   To send both reads and writes only to the secondary:

   $ pgpool [-f config_file] switch

   To switch to using only the master: 

   $ pgpool [-f config_file] -s secondary switch

   If there's only one PostgreSQL server, pgpool switch will just
   restart pgpool child processes.

11. how to get logging

   You could save messages from pgpool to a file by starting it with
   -n option:

   pgpool -n >& /tmp/pgpool.log &

   If you prefer to log to syslog, do like this:

   pgpool -n 2>&1 |logger -t pgpool -p local0.info&

12. getting internal status of pgpool

    You could use psql or whatever to obtain the internal status of
    pgpool by issuing a special SQL command:

    psql -p 9999 -c 'show pool_status' template1

             item             |                        value                         |                              description
------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------
 listen_addresses             | *                                                    | host name(s) or IP address(es) to listen to
 port                         | 9998                                                 | pgpool accepting port number
 socket_dir                   | /tmp                                                 | pgpool socket directory
 backend_host_name            |                                                      | master backend host name
 backend_port                 | 5432                                                 | master backend port number
 secondary_backend_host_name  |                                                      | secondary backend host name
 secondary_backend_port       | 5433                                                 | secondary backend port number
 num_init_children            | 32                                                   | # of children initially pre-forked
 child_life_time              | 0                                                    | if idle for this seconds, child exits
 connection_life_time         | 0                                                    | if idle for this seconds, connection closes
 child_max_connections        | 0                                                    | if max_connections received, chile exits
 max_pool                     | 2                                                    | max # of connection pool per child
 logdir                       | /tmp                                                 | logging directory
 backend_socket_dir           | /tmp                                                 | Unix domain socket directory for the PostgreSQL server
 replication_mode             | 1                                                    | non 0 if operating in replication mode
 replication_strict           | 1                                                    | non 0 if operating in strict mode
 replication_timeout          | 5000                                                 | if secondary does not respond in this milli seconds, abort the session
 load_balance_mode            | 0                                                    | non 0 if operating in load balancing mode
 weight_master                | 1.000000                                             | weight of master
 weight_secondary             | 1.000000                                             | weight of secondary
 replication_stop_on_mismatch | 0                                                    | stop replication mode on fatal error
 reset_query_list             | ABORT; RESET ALL; SET SESSION AUTHORIZATION DEFAULT; | queries issued at the end of session
 print_timestamp              | 1                                                    | if true print time stamp to each log line
 master_slave_mode            | 0                                                    | if true, operate in master/slave mode
 connection_cache             | 1                                                    | if true, cache connection pool
 health_check_timeout         | 5                                                    | health check timeout
 health_check_period          | 0                                                    | health check period
 health_check_user            | t-ishii                                              | health check user
 insert_lock                  | 1                                                    | insert lock
 ignore_leading_white_space   | 0                                                    | ignore leading white spaces
 current_backend_host_name    |                                                      | current master host name
 current_backend_port         | 5432                                                 | current master port #
 replication_enabled          | 1                                                    | non 0 if actually operating in replication mode
 master_slave_enabled         | 0                                                    | non 0 if actually operating in master/slave
 num_reset_queries            | 3                                                    | number of queries in reset_query_list
 log_statement                | 0                                                    | if true, print all statements to the log
 log_connections              | 1                                                    | if true, print incoming connections to the log
 log_hostname                 | 0                                                    | if true, resolve hostname for ps and log print
 enable_pool_hba              | 1                                                    | if true, use pool_hba.conf for client authentication
 server_status                | master( on 5432) up secondary( on 5433) up           | server status
(39 rows)

By using contrib/dblink, you can see part of the result of
show_pool_status someting like:

test=# SELECT * FROM dblink('port=9999 dbname=test', 'show pool_status')
	AS c1(pname text, val text) WHERE pname = 'port';
 pname | val  
-------+------
 port  | 9999
(1 row)

13. Playing with regression test

   $ cd /usr/local/src/postgresql-7.4.5/src/test/regress
   $ make all
   $ ./pg_regress --schedule=parallel_schedule --port=9999

14. Playing with benchmarking

   Here is a brief explanation how to play with benchmarking using pgbench/PHP/ab.

   Initialize the pgbench database.

   $ pgbench -i test
  
   Prepare PHP script. Here is an example PHP script.

   <?php
    ini_set("track_errors", "1");
    define_syslog_variables();

    $con = pg_pconnect("dbname=test user=postgres port=9999");
    if ($con == FALSE) {
      syslog(LOG_ERR, "could not connect $php_errormsg");
      trigger_error("Could not connect to DB", E_USER_ERROR);
      exit;
    }
    $aid = rand(1,10000);
    pg_query($con, "SELECT * FROM accounts WHERE aid = $aid");
    pg_close($con);
  ?>

  run ab.

  $ /usr/local/apache/bin/ab -c 100 -n 1000 "http://localhost/bench.php"

15. master/slave mode

  master/slave mode is designed to cope with master/slave replication
  softwares, such as Slony-I. To enable this mode, you need to set
  secondary host, and set true to master_slave_mode and
  load_balance_mode. Depending on the kind of qureries, pgpool
  operates as follows:

  1) if all below are satisfies, quries sent to both master and
     secondary with load balance manner.

     - PostgreSQL 7.4 or later
     - the query begins with "SELECT"(case insensitive)
     - not in a transaction block

  2) in all other case, quries are sent to only master

16. Multiple simultaneous instances of pgpool

  In order to run multiple instances of pgpool on the same server  
  simultaneously (in order to have two separate, non-conflicting  
  connection pools, for instance), create a different configuration  
  file for each instance of pgpool you wish to run.

  Then start each instance of pgpool by using the -f flag to point it  
  to the correct configuration file. For instance:

  pgpool -f /usr/local/etc/pgpool.1.conf
  pgpool -f /usr/local/etc/pgpool.2.conf

  In order for the separate instances to run without conflict, make  
  sure that the following parameters are different in the configuration  
  files:

  port
  logdir (which currently controls where pgpool drops a pid file)

  Note that each instance of pgpool should then be stopped by  
  specifying the -f flag, too. For instance:

  pgpool -f /usr/local/etc/pgpool.1.conf -m smart stop

  This would stop the first instance of pgpool running in this example.